A 2026 randomized trial of 441 older adults in Hungary found that personalized phone coaching during the COVID-19 pandemic did not significantly reduce deaths compared to general health advice. However, Gram Research analysis shows both groups improved in eating more vegetables and quitting smoking, with personalized coaching providing greater alcohol reduction benefits, particularly for women. The study suggests that remote health support helps older adults change behaviors during crises, though personalization alone may not be necessary for most improvements.
During the COVID-19 pandemic, researchers tested whether personalized lifestyle coaching delivered by phone could help people over 60 stay healthier. They compared two groups: one receiving general health advice and another receiving customized coaching focused on exercise, diet, smoking, drinking, and mental health. While both groups improved in several areas like eating more vegetables and quitting smoking, the personalized approach didn’t significantly reduce deaths or provide major additional benefits beyond standard advice. The study shows that lifestyle changes are possible during crises, but personalization alone may not be the key factor.
Key Statistics
A 2026 randomized controlled trial of 441 adults aged 60 and older found that personalized phone coaching during the COVID-19 pandemic did not significantly reduce all-cause mortality compared to general health advice, with 6 deaths in the personalized group versus 4 in the general advice group.
In the PROACTIVE-19 trial, both intervention groups showed significant increases in fruit and vegetable consumption over time, with an average increase of 0.052 servings per assessment period across 441 older adults.
Among current smokers in the 2026 PROACTIVE-19 study, smoking reduction was significant in both groups, with an average decrease of 0.372 cigarettes per day per assessment period among 441 Hungarian adults aged 60 and older.
Personalized phone coaching led to a 1.357-unit greater reduction in estimated alcohol consumption among baseline drinkers compared to general advice in the PROACTIVE-19 trial, with particularly strong effects in women.
The Quick Take
- What they studied: Whether personalized lifestyle coaching delivered over the phone could help older adults improve their health habits and reduce serious illness or death during the COVID-19 pandemic.
- Who participated: 441 adults aged 60 and older in Hungary, split into two groups. One group received general health advice, and the other received personalized coaching tailored to their specific needs.
- Key finding: Both groups improved in eating more fruits and vegetables and reducing smoking. However, personalized coaching did not significantly reduce deaths compared to general advice, and it actually led to weight gain in people with obesity.
- What it means for you: During health crises, phone-based coaching can help older adults make positive lifestyle changes. However, generic health advice may work nearly as well as personalized coaching, and weight management needs special attention during stressful times.
The Research Details
Researchers in Hungary randomly divided 441 older adults into two groups starting in March 2020, during the first COVID-19 wave. One group received general lifestyle counseling by phone, while the other received personalized coaching tailored to each person’s specific health needs. Both groups received guidance on five key areas: mental health, smoking, physical activity, diet, and alcohol use. The study tracked participants over time to see how their behaviors changed and whether they experienced serious health problems or death.
The researchers originally planned to measure COVID-19 severity, but because infection rates were lower than expected, they instead tracked all-cause mortality (death from any reason). They used statistical methods to analyze how each group’s health behaviors changed over time and compared the results between groups.
This design allowed researchers to see whether personalized coaching provided extra benefits beyond standard advice, and whether these benefits were worth the additional effort and resources.
This study design is important because it tests a practical question: during a health crisis when older adults are isolated at home, can phone-based coaching help them stay healthier? The randomized approach ensures that differences between groups are due to the coaching itself, not other factors. By tracking real-world outcomes like death and lifestyle changes, the study measures what actually matters to people’s health, not just whether they remember advice.
This is a well-designed randomized controlled trial, which is considered strong evidence. The study included a substantial number of participants (441) and tracked them over time. However, the study was open-label, meaning participants knew which group they were in, which could influence their behavior. The study also had to change its primary outcome from COVID-19 severity to all-cause mortality due to lower-than-expected infection rates, which is a limitation. The researchers used appropriate statistical methods and reported confidence intervals, showing transparency about uncertainty in their results.
What the Results Show
The main finding was that personalized coaching did not significantly reduce deaths compared to general advice. In the personalized group, 6 deaths occurred out of 227 participants, while 4 deaths occurred in the general advice group out of 214 participants. This difference was not statistically significant, meaning it could have occurred by chance.
However, both groups showed improvements in several lifestyle behaviors over time. Participants in both groups ate more fruits and vegetables as the study progressed. Among people who smoked at the start, smoking decreased significantly in both groups. Both groups also showed improvements in psychological measures, suggesting that the phone contact itself may have helped reduce stress and anxiety during the pandemic.
One important finding was that personalized coaching led to greater reductions in alcohol consumption among people who drank at baseline, particularly among women. This suggests that tailored advice may work better for specific behaviors like drinking, even if it doesn’t improve overall health outcomes.
An unexpected finding was that people with obesity in the personalized group actually gained weight during the study, while this was less pronounced in the general advice group. This suggests that the intervention may not have effectively addressed weight management, or that stress and isolation during the pandemic made weight loss difficult regardless of coaching type.
The study found that seasonal changes and different waves of the COVID-19 pandemic significantly affected physical activity and psychological distress. Participants were less active and more stressed during certain times, suggesting that external circumstances beyond the intervention influenced health behaviors. Psychological improvements were observed in both groups, indicating that regular phone contact and health-focused conversations provided mental health benefits during isolation. Gender differences emerged in alcohol reduction, with women in the personalized group showing greater improvements than men.
Previous research has shown that lifestyle interventions can improve health in older adults, but most studies were conducted before the pandemic and in person. This study adds important evidence about whether these interventions work when delivered remotely during a health crisis. The finding that personalized coaching provides limited additional benefit compared to general advice differs from some previous research suggesting personalization improves outcomes. However, the pandemic context and isolation may have changed how effective personalization can be. The improvements in smoking reduction and fruit and vegetable consumption align with previous research showing that older adults can change health behaviors when supported.
The study was open-label, meaning participants knew which group they were in, which could influence their behavior and reporting. The primary outcome had to be changed from COVID-19 severity to all-cause mortality because infection rates were lower than expected, which limits the ability to answer the original research question. The study was conducted only in Hungary, so results may not apply to other countries with different healthcare systems or pandemic experiences. The study did not include a control group that received no intervention, so we cannot determine whether either type of coaching was better than doing nothing. Weight gain in the personalized group was unexpected and not fully explained. The study did not measure adherence to the coaching, so we do not know whether participants actually followed the advice given.
The Bottom Line
For older adults during health crises: Phone-based health coaching can help improve several lifestyle behaviors, particularly smoking reduction and diet. General advice appears nearly as effective as personalized coaching for most outcomes, suggesting that simpler, less resource-intensive approaches may be sufficient. Weight management requires special attention and may need different strategies during stressful periods. Regular contact and support for mental health should be prioritized, as psychological improvements were consistent across both groups. Confidence level: Moderate for lifestyle behavior changes; Low for mortality reduction.
Older adults aged 60 and above should care about this research, particularly those isolated during health crises. Healthcare providers and public health officials should consider these findings when designing remote health programs for older populations. This is especially relevant for people with chronic conditions who cannot access in-person care. However, people younger than 60 may have different responses to remote coaching. Individuals with severe mental health conditions or those who are not comfortable with phone communication may need different approaches.
Lifestyle behavior changes like increased vegetable consumption and smoking reduction can begin within weeks of starting coaching. Psychological improvements may occur even faster, within days of receiving supportive phone contact. However, weight management changes may take several months and may require additional strategies beyond standard coaching. Mortality benefits, if they exist, would take longer to measure and were not demonstrated in this study over its duration.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does personalized health coaching over the phone help older adults during a pandemic?
Phone-based coaching helps older adults improve lifestyle behaviors like eating vegetables and quitting smoking during pandemics. A 2026 trial of 441 older adults found both personalized and general coaching produced similar benefits, suggesting that regular supportive contact matters more than customization alone.
Can remote coaching reduce death rates in older adults during COVID-19?
The PROACTIVE-19 trial found that phone coaching did not significantly reduce deaths in 441 older adults during the pandemic. While lifestyle improvements occurred, mortality benefits were not demonstrated, suggesting that remote coaching alone cannot prevent serious health outcomes without additional medical interventions.
What lifestyle changes actually work for older adults during isolation?
Research shows older adults can successfully increase vegetable intake and reduce smoking during isolation with phone support. A 2026 study of 441 adults found these changes occurred in both personalized and general coaching groups, indicating that regular contact and encouragement are key factors.
Is personalized health coaching better than generic advice for older people?
For most health outcomes, generic phone-based health advice works nearly as well as personalized coaching in older adults. The 2026 PROACTIVE-19 trial found personalization provided extra benefits only for alcohol reduction, particularly in women, suggesting targeted approaches work best for specific behaviors.
Why did people gain weight in the personalized coaching group?
The 2026 study found unexpected weight gain in the personalized group, possibly because pandemic stress and isolation made weight loss difficult regardless of coaching type. The intervention may not have adequately addressed eating patterns or physical activity barriers during the crisis.
Want to Apply This Research?
- Track daily fruit and vegetable servings and weekly smoking reduction milestones. Users can log each serving of produce and mark smoke-free days. The app should provide weekly summaries showing progress toward goals and celebrate small wins like reaching 5 servings of produce per day.
- Set up a weekly phone or video check-in reminder within the app to discuss one specific health goal. Users can choose to focus on diet, smoking, exercise, or mental health each week. The app can provide brief educational content before each check-in to prepare users for the conversation.
- Implement a monthly health behavior dashboard showing trends in fruit and vegetable intake, smoking status, physical activity minutes, and mood. Users can see whether they are improving over time and identify which behaviors are changing most. The app should alert users if weight gain is detected and suggest reviewing diet and exercise habits.
This research describes a clinical trial conducted during the COVID-19 pandemic in Hungary and may not apply to all populations or healthcare settings. The study did not demonstrate that coaching reduced mortality, and weight gain occurred in one intervention group. Older adults considering lifestyle changes should consult with their healthcare provider before starting new exercise programs or making significant dietary changes. This article summarizes research findings and should not be considered medical advice. Individual results may vary based on personal health status, medications, and other factors.
This research translation is published by Gram Research, the science division of Gram, an AI-powered nutrition tracking app.