Research shows that pregnant women who prefer evenings have lower cardiorespiratory fitness and attend fewer prenatal exercise sessions compared to morning-preference women. A study of pregnant women in randomized exercise trials found that evening-preference women had significantly lower heart and lung fitness levels, and they were substantially less likely to show up for structured exercise classes. Additionally, morning-oriented women showed improvements in protective cholesterol during pregnancy, while evening-oriented women did not, suggesting circadian preference influences both exercise participation and metabolic health during pregnancy.
A new study of pregnant women found that your natural sleep preference, whether you’re a morning person or night owl, affects how fit you stay during pregnancy and whether you stick with exercise routines. Researchers discovered that women who prefer evenings had lower heart and lung fitness compared to morning-oriented women, and they were also less likely to attend structured exercise classes during pregnancy. Interestingly, morning-oriented women showed improvements in their good cholesterol levels during pregnancy, while evening-oriented women did not. According to Gram Research analysis, understanding your natural sleep rhythm could help doctors and fitness coaches create better pregnancy exercise programs tailored to individual preferences.
Key Statistics
A randomized controlled trial of pregnant women found that greater evening preference was associated with 1.4 units lower cardiorespiratory fitness (VO2peak) after adjusting for age, body weight, and physical activity levels.
Evening-preference pregnant women showed significantly lower attendance at structured prenatal exercise sessions compared to morning-preference, more-morning-preference, and more-evening-preference women across two randomized controlled trials.
Morning-oriented pregnant women showed increases in HDL cholesterol (protective cholesterol) between 16 and 36 weeks of pregnancy, while evening-oriented women did not show significant changes in this beneficial cholesterol marker.
A study examining circadian preference in pregnant women found that chronotype differences were statistically significant across cardiorespiratory fitness, exercise compliance, and cholesterol adaptations during pregnancy.
The Quick Take
- What they studied: Whether pregnant women who naturally prefer mornings versus evenings have different fitness levels, stick with exercise programs differently, and show different changes in cholesterol during pregnancy.
- Who participated: Pregnant women enrolled in two separate exercise studies who classified themselves as morning people, somewhat morning people, somewhat evening people, or evening people.
- Key finding: Evening-preference women had noticeably lower cardiorespiratory fitness (the ability of the heart and lungs to deliver oxygen during exercise) compared to other groups. Evening-preference women also attended significantly fewer exercise sessions than morning-preference women.
- What it means for you: If you’re a night owl, you may need extra support or schedule adjustments to maintain fitness during pregnancy. Morning people may find it easier to stick with prenatal exercise routines. Talk with your healthcare provider about timing exercise to match your natural preferences.
The Research Details
Researchers combined data from two randomized controlled trials, which are considered the gold standard in medical research. Pregnant women in these studies were randomly assigned to exercise programs and asked to classify their natural sleep preference into four categories: Morning, More Morning, More Evening, or Evening types. The researchers then looked at three main outcomes: cardiorespiratory fitness (measured by a test called VO2peak, which shows how much oxygen your body can use during intense exercise), how many exercise sessions each woman attended, and changes in blood cholesterol levels measured at different points during pregnancy.
The study used statistical methods to account for other factors that might affect fitness, such as age, body weight, and how much physical activity women did outside the structured program. This helps isolate the effect of sleep preference from other influences. The researchers also looked at how cholesterol changed over time in different groups, comparing measurements taken at 16 weeks of pregnancy and 36 weeks of pregnancy.
This research approach is important because it recognizes that people have different natural rhythms, called circadian preferences or chronotypes. Previous research showed these preferences affect exercise habits in non-pregnant people, but nobody had studied whether this matters during pregnancy. By using data from controlled exercise trials, the researchers could see real-world participation patterns and actual fitness changes, not just what people reported. This gives doctors and fitness instructors practical information about why some pregnant women might struggle with exercise programs and how to better support them.
This study has several strengths: it used data from randomized controlled trials, which provide strong evidence; it measured actual fitness with objective tests rather than relying on self-reports; and it tracked real exercise attendance. However, the study has limitations. The exact number of participants isn’t specified in the abstract, making it harder to judge how reliable the findings are. The researchers note that their findings about cholesterol changes are exploratory and need confirmation in larger studies. The study also relied on women self-classifying their sleep preference rather than using objective measurements of circadian rhythm.
What the Results Show
Evening-preference pregnant women had significantly lower cardiorespiratory fitness compared to all other groups. Specifically, each step toward greater evening preference was associated with a decrease of about 1.4 units in VO2peak (a measure of how much oxygen the body can use), even after accounting for age, body weight, and overall physical activity. This difference is meaningful because cardiorespiratory fitness during pregnancy is linked to better health outcomes for both mother and baby.
Exercise attendance showed a clear pattern across chronotype groups. Evening-preference women attended significantly fewer exercise sessions than morning-preference women, more-morning-preference women, and more-evening-preference women. This suggests that the timing of exercise programs may not align well with evening-preference women’s natural rhythms, making it harder for them to participate consistently.
When researchers looked at cholesterol changes during pregnancy, they found an interesting difference. Morning-oriented women showed an increase in HDL cholesterol (the protective kind that’s good for heart health) between 16 and 36 weeks of pregnancy. In contrast, evening-oriented women did not show this beneficial increase. This suggests that circadian preference might influence how the body responds metabolically to pregnancy and exercise.
The study found that chronotype differences were statistically significant across multiple outcomes, suggesting this isn’t just random variation but a real pattern. The interaction between time during pregnancy and chronotype for HDL cholesterol suggests that the body’s response to pregnancy changes differently depending on sleep preference. This opens questions about whether evening-preference women might need different exercise timing or intensity to achieve the same metabolic benefits as morning-preference women.
Previous research in non-pregnant populations showed that evening-preference people tend to be less physically active and have lower fitness levels. This study extends that finding to pregnancy, showing the pattern holds even during this special time when exercise is particularly important. The findings align with research showing that circadian preference affects exercise habits and fitness outcomes across different life stages. However, this appears to be the first study specifically examining these associations during pregnancy, making it a novel contribution to prenatal health research.
The study has several important limitations. First, the exact sample size is not provided, which makes it difficult to assess how confident we should be in the findings. Second, women self-classified their chronotype rather than having it measured objectively through sleep tracking or biological markers, which could introduce inaccuracy. Third, the findings about cholesterol changes are described as exploratory, meaning they’re preliminary and need confirmation in larger studies before we can be confident in them. Fourth, the study doesn’t explain why evening-preference women attended fewer sessions, whether it’s due to scheduling conflicts, energy levels, or other factors. Finally, the study was conducted in specific populations participating in research trials, so the findings may not apply equally to all pregnant women.
The Bottom Line
Moderate confidence: If you’re a night owl, consider scheduling prenatal exercise at times that align better with your natural energy patterns, such as later in the day or evening. Morning people should feel confident that morning exercise routines align with their natural preferences. All pregnant women should aim for regular physical activity as recommended by their healthcare provider, regardless of chronotype. High confidence: Talk with your doctor or prenatal fitness instructor about your natural sleep preference and ask for help scheduling exercise at times when you’re most likely to participate consistently.
Pregnant women, especially those who identify as evening-preference types and struggle to stick with exercise routines, should pay attention to these findings. Healthcare providers, prenatal fitness instructors, and exercise physiologists should consider chronotype when designing or recommending prenatal exercise programs. Women concerned about cardiovascular fitness and cholesterol levels during pregnancy may find this information relevant. This research is less relevant for women who already exercise consistently regardless of time of day or those with medical reasons to avoid exercise.
Changes in cardiorespiratory fitness typically develop over weeks to months of consistent exercise. The cholesterol changes observed in this study occurred between 16 and 36 weeks of pregnancy, suggesting that metabolic adaptations take several months. If you adjust your exercise timing to match your chronotype, you might notice improved consistency within 1 to 2 weeks, with fitness improvements following over 4 to 8 weeks of regular participation.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does being a night owl affect how fit you stay during pregnancy?
Research shows evening-preference pregnant women have lower cardiorespiratory fitness compared to morning-preference women. Evening-preference women also attend fewer prenatal exercise sessions, which may contribute to lower fitness levels. Adjusting exercise timing to match your natural preference could help improve participation.
Why do morning people stick with prenatal exercise better than night owls?
The study found evening-preference women attended significantly fewer exercise sessions than other groups, but doesn’t explain why. Possible reasons include scheduling conflicts, lower energy in the morning, or misalignment between program timing and natural rhythms. Evening-preference women may benefit from programs scheduled later in the day.
Does your sleep schedule affect cholesterol during pregnancy?
Morning-oriented pregnant women showed increases in HDL cholesterol (good cholesterol) between 16 and 36 weeks of pregnancy, while evening-oriented women did not. This suggests circadian preference may influence how the body’s metabolism responds to pregnancy, though researchers note this finding needs confirmation in larger studies.
Should I change my exercise time if I’m a night owl and pregnant?
If you’re an evening-preference person struggling to attend morning exercise classes, scheduling prenatal exercise for later in the day or evening may help you participate more consistently. Talk with your healthcare provider about timing options that work with your natural sleep preference and energy patterns.
Is this research strong enough to change how prenatal exercise programs are scheduled?
The study provides meaningful evidence that chronotype affects exercise participation during pregnancy, but researchers note the sample size isn’t specified and some findings are exploratory. The results suggest considering chronotype when designing programs, but larger confirmation studies would strengthen these recommendations.
Want to Apply This Research?
- Log your chronotype preference (morning, more morning, more evening, or evening) in your profile, then track exercise session attendance and time of day completed. Compare your attendance rates when exercising at different times to identify your optimal exercise window.
- If you’re an evening-preference user, set reminders for evening or late-afternoon exercise sessions rather than morning slots. Create a prenatal exercise routine scheduled for times when you naturally have more energy. Track which time slots result in the most consistent attendance and adjust your routine accordingly.
- Monitor exercise attendance rates by time of day over 4-week periods. Track how your energy levels correlate with exercise timing. If using a fitness tracker, note your heart rate recovery and perceived exertion at different times of day to identify when you exercise most effectively. Share this data with your prenatal care provider to optimize your fitness plan.
This research provides evidence about associations between sleep preference and exercise participation during pregnancy, but individual results vary. Pregnant women should consult their healthcare provider before starting or changing any exercise program. This information is not a substitute for medical advice. Women with pregnancy complications or medical conditions should get personalized guidance from their prenatal care team about appropriate exercise timing and intensity. The findings about cholesterol changes are exploratory and should not be used as the sole basis for medical decisions.
This research translation is published by Gram Research, the science division of Gram, an AI-powered nutrition tracking app.